Analogy Faithfulness Evaluation

Instructions

Please carefully evaluate the analogy presented below. Your task is to assess the structural faithfulness of the mapping between the target concept and the source domain.

How to Evaluate

• Structural Similarity (1-5): How structurally similar are the properties and role of these two entities? For example, do an array and a parking garage have a similar structure? Does a car in a parking garage represent the same part of the structure that an element of an array does?
• Factual Correctness (1-5): Are the statements implied by this row factually correct in both domains? For example, does an array actually have numerical indices (the entities can be factually incorrect)? Does a parking garage actually have parking spots?
• Rule Violation: Does this mapping violate any of the formal rules or constraints of the target concept?

Global Evaluation

• System Coherence (1-5): Do the target and source entities form a coherent system when considered together? As in: how similar to each other are the systems presented by each column of the table as a whole?
• Helpfulness (1-5): Does this analogy help you understand the target concept?

Important Notes

• Evaluate only what is shown - do not use external knowledge beyond basic CS familiarity
• You can return to these instructions at any time